Mount Sinai Real Estate Guide


    Originally known as Nonowatucket, the area of Mount Sinai was inhabited by Native Americans until European settlers obtained a deed for the land in the 1660s. During the American Revolution, the area was occupied by the British until the Americans reclaimed the area with a successful attack at Cedar Beach, on a historical trail that remains today.

    Mount Sinai then became an agricultural town that later boomed into a resort spot in the late 19th century, where travelers would stay to enjoy the beautiful beaches and tranquil setting. During the mid-20th century, Mount Sinai became a residential suburban community, and continues to thrive as such today.


    Situated on the North Shore, Mount Sinai is in Suffolk County, New York. It’s conveniently located next to Port Jefferson, offering the best of both land and sea to its residents and visitors. Whether you want to be close to the beach, or relax in the comfort of a quiet neighborhood, or take a trip to a nearby city, you can indulge any whim in this gorgeous town.

    Family Life

    Maybe your new family is just starting out on life’s adventures, or perhaps you have a busy household bustling with children of all ages. Whatever the case may be, the town of Mount Sinai offers a family-oriented layout that is sure to welcome your household. With its excellent school district that has a small student to teacher ratio, community events, and wonderful outdoor activities, Mt. Sinai is the perfect place for your family to call

    Attractions & Activities

    Because Mount Sinai is a residential town that’s situated right next to the beach, residents and visitors enjoy an abundance of unique attractions and wonderful activities for everyone.

    Visit the Mount Sinai Marina for a gorgeous harbor experience that offers a stunning backdrop and view for all to enjoy. Spend the afternoon at the beach swimming or laying out in the sun, take an exciting boat ride, relax on the pier and do some fishing off the pier, or go for a walk at any time of day to enjoy the scenery.

    Across from the Marina is the ever-popular Cedar Beach, one of Mt. Sinai’s most bustling sites. Located on the Long Island Sound, it has two beaches, a scenic walking trail, a boat launch ramp, and a fishing pier. It’s very
    family-friendly, and children will love the playground and basketball courts available on site. Purchase refreshing drinks and delicious snacks at the beach bar or concession stand. Don’t miss out on all the fun summer fairs and festivals at Cedar Beach!

    For a pleasant community center and park in Mount Sinai, The Heritage Center is the place to be. It provides the community with an enjoyable place for recreation, education, relaxation, and more. Residents may rent the Center
    for private events, weddings, birthday parties, and the like.

    Another great location in Mt. Sinai is Willow Creek, a premier golf and country club. The perfect setting for social and business interaction, the site offers breathtaking views and gorgeous green landscapes for locals to
    enjoy an ultimate golfing or dining experience.

    Shopping & Dining

    Though a small town, residents can still meet their shopping needs. There are shops located throughout the area for home decor, fashion apparel, music, gifts, jewelry, and more. Shop at the Mount Sinai Green Market for fresh, locally-grown produce, diary, and baked goods.

    Experience a handful of diverse dining establishments in Mount Sinai. Ralph’s Fishing Station is a hidden gem where you can grab bait, food, and drinks before you go boating, or you can sit on the dock for amazing views, friends, and great music. To spice things up with some ethnic Turkish and Mediterranean food, Mavi Grill & Deli is sure to please, and is rated #1 on TripAdvisor. A local landmark situated in Mt. Sinai’s historical district, Savino’s Hideaway is a favorite spot to dine for delicious Italian entrees and cocktails on a night out on the town. For any sushi lovers in the family, Midori Sushi & Steakhouse is a Japanese restaurant with a menu that offers unique rolls and hibachi, and just across the street Mount Sinai Sushi offers the most unique selection of rolls I’ve seen on any sushi menu–all delicious!

    Reviews on Zillow
    "I cant say enough about my experience with Donna as a seller and a buyer. I needed to sell my home quickly. Donna and her team worked seamlessly ... more "
    by stephfriend68
    "Amanda is very proactive and is a good listener. She made the process easy and pleasant. She was pragmatic and reasonable. Her photographer took great ... more "
    by GillianStewart